Year of release: 2004
Running time: 101 mins
Certificate: 15
Director: Paul W.S. Anderson
Starring: Sanaa Lathan, Raoul Bova, Lance Henriksen, Ewen Bremner, Colin Salmon
Putting two popular franchises together into one film was always going to be difficult, and certainly frowned upon when first announced. Such is where we find ourselves with Paul W.S. Anderson’s Alien and Predator mash-up.
That’s not to say this film is bad. It had potential to be better, but fell short of the mark, but it wasn’t awful. The novelty of Alien vs Predator was captured perfectly in this one. A war between the two, or more like a game for the Predators who hunt the Aliens and kill them to prove they are true warriors, now that bit the fans can get with. It’s the whole back story of the relationship between these two powerful creatures that let this film down. It was a bit vague and, to be honest, shoddy.
Put that aside though and the film does deliver some good punches. The one on one fights between the two creatures, though a little stiff in movement sometimes (clearly a guy in the Alien suit at these said times), are thrilling to behold, with the outcome never truly set in stone.
The story telling is reminiscent of these films, in that we are thrown straight into the action (a death in 2 minutes alone), followed by an introduction to the group who will be put through their paces and a slow start before we get to the bloody action. At a breath-taking pace we travel through the gory story and end on a thrilling fight and somewhat of a cliffhanger.
Character wise we have a collection of accents, Scottish, English, American etc, and nothing much else. In fact the introduction of them at the beginning is dry and makes most of them out to be dull and insignificant. The sharing of the discovery of the pyramid is the only thing to spice things up, as it promises some action. In fact, the characters seem so insignificant it becomes difficult to determine whose on whose team, that also going for the Aliens and Predators as well.
The only remaining thing of note is the very Indiana Jones/Lara Croft feel with the temple, which proves to be just as deadly as the creatures it contains. Yet all the hidden traps and moving pieces sometimes take away from some of the horror elements unfortunately. Let’s be honest: the audience is here to see two great baddies fight to the death… another reason why the humans are mostly pushed to the back.
Overall, the Aliens and the Predators mashed up well together. Visually, its stunning. However, it does begin to feel like the humans have no real significance, being pushed aside whilst mummy and daddy fight (fight amongst yourselves about who’s who). These franchises seem to have lost the ability to create great characters in later releases, allowing the monsters to be the real stars. But what these franchises need are some powerful human figures for the audiences to connect with and who can stand up to these monsters at least somewhat, rather than running away pathetically, that is if they want to drive their stories into the realm of lasting memory.
A 6.9 out of 10.